I have been reading a lot lately regarding the relatively recent debate of science vs. magic. Like pirates and ninjas, these two factions cannot seem to get along, forming uneasy alliances at the best of times. I have studied both science and magic, and I practice both in my personal life to great effect. This post is a bit tongue-in-cheek, but illustrates a serious point: there really is no conflict.
If you will indulge me for a moment, I will tell you a story. It is a true story… except that I took some liberty with the actual conversation.
Marco Polo is off traveling the world, and comes to India. He meets with an Indian prince, and they are exchanging stories of their homelands, and come to differences in weather.
Marco Polo: In my country, it gets so cold in the winter that water turns solid. We call it “ice”. It is clear and hard, and shatters into shards like glass.
Indian Prince: No! Get out of town!
Marco Polo: It’s true! I have seen it myself!
Indian Prince: If it is true, you must show me the proof! In fact, I have a bowl of water right here…
Marco Polo: No, you see… it has to be cold.. and I have no means to build a heat-transfer engine right now… and, um… I really cannot do it.
Indian Prince, laughing: Ah! I see you are just trying to impress me with amusing tales. I have traveled the length and breadth of my land, and seen no force that can turn running water into this hard substance you speak of. My own senses tell me such a thing is impossible, and you can offer me no proof to the contrary. This “ice” is simply too fantastic to be believed!
Marco Polo, depressed: Lets talk about something else…
This story is one that many in the magical community can relate to. We have experienced things first-hand, and know them to be true. The skeptics ask for proof. We find ourselves in the position of Marco Polo, with no way to bring his block of ice from England to India without refrigeration. What I am saying is that the debate over science and magic often comes down to a problem of logistics. That we have no way – yet – to show a skeptic the proof, does not invalidate out direct experience.
The Scientific Community as a whole should be more sensitive to this. Things work, whether or not science can explain why. As Tom Baker in Doctor Who once said, “Nothing is unexplainable, only unexplained.” So lighten up, scientific community!